Hitler
Psychological Analysis & Reconstruction
Part II
His early conflicts expressed in symbolic form.
Unconsciously, all the emotions he had once felt for his mother became transferred to
Germany. This transfer of affect was relatively easy inasmuch as Germany, like his mother,
was young and vigorous and held promise of a great future under suitable circumstances.
Furthermore, he felt shut off from Germany as he now felt shut off from his mother, even
though he secretly wished to be with her. Germany became a symbol of his ideal mother and
his sentiments are clearly expressed in his writings and speeches. A few excerpts will
serve to illustrate the transfer of emotion:
"The longing grew stronger to go there (Germany) where since my early youth I had
been drawn by secret wishes and secret love."
"What I first had looked upon as an impassable chasm now spurred me on to greater
love for my country than ever before."
"An unnatural separation from the great common Motherland."
"I appeal to those who, severed from the Motherland, ...and who now in painful
emotion long for the hour that will allow them to return to the arms of the beloved
mother."
It is significant that although Germans, as a whole, invariably refer to Germany as the
"Fatherland", Hitler almost always refers to it as the "Motherland.
Just as Germany was ideally suited to symbolize his mother, so was Austria ideally
suited to symbolize his father. Like his father, Austria was old, exhausted and decaying
from within. He therefore transferred all his unconscious hatred from his father to the
Austrian state. He could now give vent to all his pent-up emotions without exposing
himself to the dangers he believed he would have encountered had he expressed these same
feelings towards the persons really involved. In MEIN KAMPF he frequently refers to the
Austrian state, for example, in terms such as these:
"... an intense love for my native German-Austrian country and a bitter hatred
against the Austrian state."
"With proud admiration I compared the rise of the Reich with the decline of the
Austrian state."
The alliance between Austria and Germany served to symbolize the marriage of his mother
and father. Over and over again we find references to this alliance and we can see clearly
how deeply he resented the marriage of his parents because he felt that his father was a
detriment to his mother and only through the death of the former could the latter obtain
her freedom and find her salvation. A few quotations will illustrate his sentiments:
"And who could keep faith with an imperial dynasty which betrayed the cause of the
German people for its own ignominious ends, a betrayal that occurred again and
again."
"What grieved us most was the fact that the whole system, was morally protected by
the alliance with Germany, and thus Germaey herself...walked by the side of the
corpse."
"...It suffices to state here that from my earliest youth I came to a conviction
which never deserted me, but on the contrary grew stronger and stronger: that the
protection of the German race presumed the destruction of Austria...that, above all else,
the Royal House of Hapsburg was destined to bring misfortune upon the German nation."
"Since my heart had never beaten for an Austrian monarchy but only for a German
Reich, I could only look upon the hour of the ruin of this state as the beginning of the
salvation of the German nation."
When we have grasped the significance of this transference of affect we have made a
long step in the direction of understanding Hitler's actions. Unconsciously he is not
dealing with nations composed of millions of individuals but is trying to solve his
personal conflicts and rectify the injustices of his childhood. Unable to enter into a
"give-and-take" relationship with other human beings which might afford him an
opportunity of resolving his conflicts in a realistic manner, he projects his personal
problems on great nations and then tries to solve them on this unrealistic level. His
microcosm has been inflated into a macrocosm.
We can now understand why Hitler fell on his knees and thanked God when the last war
broke out. To him it did not mean simply a war, as such, but an opportunity of fighting
for his symbolic mother - of proving his manhood and of being accepted by her. It was
inevitable that he would seek enlistment in the German Army rather than in the Austrian
Army and it was also inevitable, under these circumstances, that he would be a good and
obedient soldier. Unconsciously it was as though he were a little boy who was playing the
part of a man while his mother stood by and watched him. Her future welfare was his great
concern and in order to prove his love he was willing, if need be, to sacrifice his own
life for her.
The effects of Germany's defeat.
Everything went smoothly as long as he felt sure that all would turn out well in the
end. He never complained about the hardships that were imposed on him and he never
grumbled with the other men. He was happy in what he was doing and met the trials and
tribulations of army life with his chin up until he discovered that things were going
badly and that his symbolic mother was about to be degraded as he had imagined his real
mother had been degraded in his childhood. To him it was as if his mother was again the
victim of a sexual assault. This time it was the November Criminals and the Jews who were
guilty of the foul deed and he promptly transferred his repressed hate to these new
perpetrators.
When he became fully aware of Germany's defeat he reacted in a typically hysterical
manner. He refused to accept or adjust to the situation on a reality level. Instead, he
reacted to this event as he probably reacted to the discovery of his parents in
intercourse. He writes:
"I stumbIed and tottered rearwards with burning eyes...Already a few hours later
the eyes had turned into burning coals; it had become dark around me."
In another place he writes:
"While everything began to go black again before my eyes, stumbling, I groped my
way back to the dormitory, threw myself on my cot and buried my burning head in the covers
and pillows."
At the time this happened he had been exposed to a slight attack of mustard gas. He
immediately believed that he was blinded and speechless. Although he spent several weeks
in hospital, neither his symptoms nor the development of the illness corresponded to those
found in genuine gas cases. It has been definitely established that both the blindness and
the mutism were of an hysterical nature. The physician who treated him at that time found
his case so typical of hysterical symptoms in general that for years after the war he used
it as an illustration in his courses given at a prominent German medical school. We know
from a great many other cases that during the onset of such attacks the patient behaves in
exactly the same manner as he did earlier in his life when confronted by a situation with
the same emotional content. It is as though the individual were actually reliving the
earlier experience over again. In Hitler's case this earlier experience was almost
certainly the discovery of his parents in intercourse and that he interpreted this as a
brutal assault in which he was powerless. He refused to believe what his eyes told him and
the experience left him speechless.
That this interpretation is correct is evidenced by his imagery in dealing with the
event later on. Over and over again we find figures of speech such as these:
"...by what wiles the soul of the German has been raped."
"...our German pacifists will pass over in silence the most bloody rape of the
nation."
which illustrate his sentiments very clearly.
The origins of his belief in his mission and his longing for immortality.
It was while he was in the hospital suffering from hysterical blindness and mutism that
he had the vision that he would liberate the Germans from their bondage and make Germany
great. It was this vision that set him on his present political career and which has had
such a determining influence on the course of world events. More than anything else it was
this vision that convinced him that he was chosen by Providence and that he had a great
mission to perform. This is probably the most outstanding characteristic of Hitler's
mature personality and it is this which guides him with the "precision of a
sleepwalker."
From an analysis of many other cases we know that such convictions never result from an
adult experience alone. In order to carry conviction they must reawaken earlier beliefs
which have their roots far back in childhood. It is, of course, nothing unusual for a
child to believe that he is some special creation and destined to do great things before
he dies. One can almost say that every child passes through such a period on his way to
growing up. In many people remnants of such early beliefs are observable inasmuch as they
feel or believe that Fate or Luck or Providence or some extra-natural power has chosen
them for special favors. In most of these cases, however, the adult individual only half
believes that this is really so even when a whole series of favorable events may make the
hypothesis plausible. Only rarely do we find a firm conviction of this kind in adulthoed
and then only when there were extenuating circumstances in childhood which made such a
belief necessary and convincing.
In Hitler's case the extenuating circumstances are relatively clear. Mention has
already been made of the fact that his mother had given birth to at least two and possibly
three children, all of whom had died prior to his own birth. He, himself, was a frail and
rather sickly infant. Under these circumstances, his mother undoubtedly exerted herself to
the utmost to keep him alive. He was unquestionably spoiled during this period and his
survival was probably the great concern of the family as well as of the neighbors. From
his earliest days there was, no doubt, considerable talk in the household about the death
of the other children and constant comparisons between their progress and his own.
Children first become aware of death as a phenomenon very early in life and in view of
these unusual circumstances it may have dawned on Hitler even earlier than with most
children. The thought of death, in itself, is inconceivable to a small child and they
usually are able to form only the vaguest conception of what it means or implies before
they push it out of their minds, for later consideration. In Hitler's case, however, it
was a living issue and the fears of the mother were in all likelihood communicated to
him. As he pondered the problem in his immature way, he probably wondered why the
others died while he continued to live. The natural conclusion for a child to draw would
be that he was favored in some way or that he was chosen to live for some particular
purpose. The belief that he was the "chosen one" would have been reinforced by
the fact that as far as his mother was concerned he was very much the chosen one in
comparison with her two step-children who were also living in the home at that time.
This belief must have been strengthened considerably when, at the age of five, his baby
brother was born. This baby brother has undoubtedly played a much more important role in
Adolph's life than has been acknowledged by his biographers. The pertinent fact at the
moment, however, is that this brother too died before he was six years old. It was
Adolph's first real experience with death and it must have brought up the problem of death
again in a much more vivid form. Again, we can surmise, he asked himself why they died
while he continues to be saved. The only plausible answer to a child at that age would be
that he must be under divine protection. This may seem far-fetched and yet, as an adult,
Hitler tells us that he felt exactly this way when he was at the front during the war,
even before he had the vision.
Then, too, he speculated on why it is that comrades all around him are killed while he
is saved and again he comes to the conclusion that Providence must be protecting him.
Perhaps the exemplary courage he displayed in carrying messages at the front was due to
the feeling that some kindly Fate was watching over him. Throughout MEIN KAMPF we find
this type of thinking. It was Fate that had him born so close to the German border; it was
Fate that sent him to Vienna to suffer with the masses; it was Fate that caused him to do
many things. The experience he reports at the front, when a voice told him to pick up his
plate and move to another section of the trench just in time to escape a shell which
killed all his comrades, must certainly have strengthened this belief to a marked degree
and paved the way for his vision later on.
The Messiah. complex.
Another influence may have helped to solidify this system of belief. Among patients we
very frequently find that children who are spoiled at an early age and establish a strong
bond with their mother tend to question their paternity. Eldest children in particular are
prone to such doubts and it is most marked in cases where the father is much older than
the mother. In Hitler's case the father was twenty-three years older, or almost twice the
age of the mother. Just why this should be is not clear, from a psychological point of
view, but in such cases there is a strong tendency to believe that their father is not
their real father and to ascribe their birth to some kind of supernatural conception.
Usually such beliefs are dropped as the child grows older. It can be observed in
young children, however, and can often be recovered in adults under suitable conditions.
Due to the unsympathetic and brutal nature of his father we may suppose that there was an
added incentive in rejecting him as his real father and postulating some other origin to
himself.
The problem is not important in itself at the moment except insofar as it may help to
throw some light on the origins of Hitler's conviction in his mission and his belief that
he is guided by some extra-natural power which communicates to him what he should and
should not do under varying circumstances. This hypothesis is tenable in view of the fact
that during his stay in Vienna, when still in his early twenties, he grew a beard and
again directly after the war when he again grew a Christ-like beard. Then, too, when he
was a student at the Benedictine school his ambition was to join the Church and become an
abbot or priest. All of these give some indication of a Messiah complex long before he had
started on his meteoric career and become an open competitor of Christ for the affections
of the German people.
Fear of death and desire for immortality.
Although beliefs of this kind are common during childhood they are usually dropped or
are modified as the individual becomes older and more experienced. In Hitler's case,
however, the reverse has taken place. The conviction became stronger as he grew
older until, at the present time, it is the core of his thinking. Under these
circumstances, we must suppose that some powerful psychological stream continued to
nourish these infantile modes of thought. This psychological stream is probably, as it is
in many other cases, a fear of death. It seems logical to suppose that in the course of
his early deliberations on the deaths of his brothers his first conclusion was probably
that all the others die and that consequently he too would die. His fear would not be
allayed by his mother's constant concern over his well-being, which he may have
interpreted as an indication that the danger was imminent. Such a conclusion would
certainly be a valid one for a child to make under the circumstances.
The thought of his own death, however, is almost unbearable to a small child. Nothing
is quite so demoralizing as the constant dread of self-annihilation. It gnaws away day and
night and prevents him from enjoying the good things that life affords.
To rid himself of this devastating fear becomes his major objective. This is not easily
accomplished, especially when all available evidence seems to corroborate the validity of
the fear. In order to offset its potency he is almost driven to deny its reality by
adopting the belief that he is of divine origin and that Providence is protecting him from
all harm. Only by use of such a technique is the child able to convince himself that, he
will not die. We must also remember that in Hitler's case there was not only the
unusual succession of deaths of siblings, but there was also the constant menace of his
father's brutality which helped make the fear more intense than in most children. This
danger could easily be exaggerated in Hitler's mind due to a sense of guilt concerning his
feelings towards his respective parents and what his father might do to him if he
discovered his secret. These feelings would tend to increase his fear of death at the same
time that they caused him to reject his father. Both tendencies would serve to nourish the
belief that he was of divine origin and was under its protection.
It is my belief that this basic fear of death is still present and active in Hitler's
character at the present time. As time goes on and he approaches the age when he might
reasonably expect to die, this infantile fear asserts itself more strongly. As a mature,
intelligent man he knows that the law of nature is such that his physical self is destined
to die. He is still not able, however, to accept the fact that he as an individual, his
psyche, will also die. It is this element in his psychological structure which demands
that he become immortal. Most people are able to take the sting out of this fear of death
through religious beliefs in life after death, or through the feeling that a part of them,
at least, will continue to go on living in their children. In Hitler's, case, both of
these normal channels have been closed and he has been forced to seek immortality in
a more direct form. He must arrange to go on living in the German people for at least a
thousand years to come. In order to do this, he must oust Christ as a competitor and usurp
his place in the lives of the German people.
In addition to evidence drawn from experience with patients which would make this
hypothesis tenable, we have the evidence afforded by Hitler's own fears and attitudes. We
have discussed these in detail in Section IV. Fear of assassination, fear of poisoning,
fear of premature death, etc., all deal with the problem of death in an uncamouflaged
form. One can, of course, maintain that in view or his position all these fears are more
or less justified. There is certainly some truth in this contention but we also notice
that as time goes on these fears have increased considerably until now they have reached
the point where the precautions for his own safety far exceed those of any of his
predecessors. As long as he could hold a plebescite every now and then and reassure
himself that the German people loved him and wanted him, he felt better. Now that this is
no longer possible, he has no easy way of curbing the fear and his uncertainty in the
future becomes greater. There can be little doubt concerning his faith in the results of
the plebescites. He was firmly convinced that the 98% vote, approving his actions, really
represented the true feelings of the German people. He believed this because he needed
such reassurance from time to time in order to carry on with a fairly easy mind and
maintain his delusions.
When we turn to his fear of cancer we find no justification whatever for his belief,
especially in view of the fact that several outstanding specialists in this disease have
assured him that it is without foundation. Nevertheless, it is one of his oldest fears and
he continues to adhere to it in spite of all the expert testimony to the contrary. This
fear becomes intelligible when we remember that his mother died following an operation for
cancer of the breast. In connection with his fear of death we must not forget his
terrifying nightmares from which he awakes in a cold sweat and acts as though he were
being suffocated. If our hypothesis is correct, namely, that a fear of death is one of the
powerful unconscious streams which drive Hitler on in his mad career, then we can expect
that as the war progresses and as he becomes older the fear will continue to increase.
With the progress of events along their present course, it will be more and more difficult
for him to feel that his mission is fulfilled and that he has successfully cheated death
and achieved immortality in the German people. Nevertheless, we can expect him to keep on
trying to the best of his ability as long as a ray of hope remains. The great danger is
that if he feels that he cannot achieve immortality as the Great Redeemer he may seek it
as the Great Destroyer who will live on in the minds of the German people for a
thousand years to come. He intimated this in a conversation with Rauschning when he
said:
"We shall not capitulate -- no, never. We may be destroyed, but if we are, we
shall drag a world with us--a world in flames."
With him, as with many others of his type, it may well be a case of immortality of any
kind at any price.
Sexual development.
Closely interwoven with several of the themes which have already been elaborated is the
development of his sexual life. From what we know about his mother's excessive cleanliness
and tidiness we may assume that she employed rather stringent measures during the toilet
training period of her children. This usually results in a residual tension in this area
and is regarded by the child as a severe frustration which arouses feelings of hostility.
This facilitates an alliance with his infantile aggression which finds an avenue for
expression through anal activities and fantasies. These usually center around soiling,
humiliation and destruction, and form the basis of a sadistic character.
Here, again, we may assume that the experience was more intense in Hitler's case than
in the average due to the strong attachment and spoiling of his mother in early infancy.
Unaccustomed to minor frustrations which most children must learn to endure, prior to the
toilet training, he was poorly equipped to deal with this experience which plays an
important role in the life of all infants. Even now, as an adult, we find Hitler unable to
cope with frustrating experiences on a mature level. That a residual tension from this
period still exists in Hitler is evidenced by the frequency of imagery in his speaking and
writing which deal with dung and dirt and smell. A few illustrations may help to clarify
his unconscious preoccupation with these subjects.
"You don't understand: we are just passing a magnet over a dunghill, and we shall
see presently how much iron was in the dunghill and has clung to the magnet." (By
'dunghill' Hitler meant the German people.)
"And when he (the Jew) turns the treasures over in his hand they are transformed
into dirt and dung."
"...Ones hands hands seize slimy jelly; it slips through one's fingers only to
collect again in the next moment."
"Charity is sometimes actually comparable to the manure which is spread on the
field, not out of love for the latter, but out of precaution for one's own benefit later
on."
"...dragged into the dirt and filth of the lowest depths."
"Later the smell of these caftan wearers made me ill. Added to this were their
dirty clothes and their none too heroic appearance."
"...The rottenness of artificially nurtured conditions of peace has more than once
stunk to high heaven."
His libidinal development, however, was not arrested at this point but progressed to
the genital level at which the Oedipus complex, already referred to, developed. This
complex, as we have seen, was aggravated by his mother's pregnancy at precisely the age
when the complex normally reaches its greatest intensity. In addition to accentuating his
hatred for his father and estranging him from his mother, we can assume that this event at
this particular time served to generate an abnormal curiosity in him. He, like all
children at this age, must have wondered how the unborn child got into the mother's
stomach and how it was going to get out.
These three reactions have all played an important part in Hitler's psychosexual
development. It would seem from the evidence that his aggressive fantasies towards the
father reached such a point that he became afraid of the possibility of retaliation if his
secret desires were discovered. The retaliation he probably feared was that his father
would castrate him or injure his genital capacity in some way - a fear which is later
expressed in substitute form in his syphilophobia. Throughout MEIN KAMPF he comes back to
the topic of syphilis again and again and spends almost an entire chapter describing its
horrors. In almost all cases we find that a fear of this sort is rooted in a fear of
genital injury during childhood. In many cases this fear was so overpowering that the
child abandoned his genital sexuality entirely and regressed to earlier stages of
libidinal development. In order to maintain these repressions later in life he uses the
horrors of syphilis as a justification for his unconscious fear that genital sexuality is
dangerous for him, and also as a rationalization for his avoidance of situations in which
his earlier desires might be aroused.
In abandoning the genital level of libidinal development the individual becomes
impotent as far as heterosexual relations are concerned. It would appear, from the
evidence, that some such process took place during Hitler's early childhood. Throughout
his early adult life, in Vienna, in the Army, in Munich, in Landesberg, no informant has
reported a heterosexual relationship. In fact, the informants of all these periods make a
point of the fact that he had absolutely no interest in women or any contact with them.
Since he has come to power his peculiar relationship to women has been so noticeable that
many writers believe that he is asexual. Some have surmised that he suffered a genital
injury during the last war, others that he is homosexual. The former hypothesis, for which
there is not a shred of real evidence, is almost certainly false. The second hypothesis we
will examine later on.
The diffusion of the sexual instinct.
When a regression of this kind take [sic] place the sexual instinct usually becomes
diffuse and many organs which have yielded some sexual stimulation in the past
become permanently invested with sexual significance. The eyes, for example, may become a
substitute sexual organ and seeing then takes on a sexual significance. This seems to have
happened in Hitler's case for a number of informants have commented on his delight in
witnessing strip-tease and nude dancing numbers on the stage. On such occasions he can
never see enough to satisfy him even though he uses opera glasses in order to observe more
closely. Strip-tease artists are frequently invited to the Brown House, in Munich, to
perform in private and there is evidence that he often invites girls to Berchtesgaden for
the purpose of exhibiting their bodies. On his walls are numerous pictures of obscene
nudes which conceal nothing and he takes particular delight in looking through a
collection of pornographic pictures which Hoffmann has made for him. We also know the
extreme pleasure he derives from huge pageants, circus performances, opera, and
particularly the movies of which he can never get enough. He has told informants that he
gave up flying not only because of the danger involved but because he could not see enough
of the country. For this reason, automobile travel is his favorite form of transportation.
From all of this it is evident that seeing has a special sexual significance for him. This
probably accounts for his "hypnotic glance" which has been the subject of
comment by so many writers. Some have reported that at their first meeting Hitler fixated
them with his eyes as if "to bore through them." It is also interesting
that when the other person meets his stare, Hitler turns his eyes to the ceiling and keeps
them there during the interview. Then, too, we must not forget that in the moment of
crisis his hysterical attack manifested itself in blindness.
In addition to the eyes, the anal region has also become highly sexualised and both
faeces and buttocks become sexual objects. Due to early toilet training, certain
inhibitions have been set up which prevent their direct expression. However, we find so
many instances of imagery of this kind, particularly in connection with sexual topics,
that we must assume that this area has unusual sexual significance. The nature of this
significance we will consider in a moment.
The mouth, too, seems to have become invested as an erogenous zone of great importance.
Few authors or informants have neglected to mention Hitler's peculiar dietary habits. He
consumes tremendous quantities of sweets, candies, cakes, whipped cream, etc., in the
course of a day in addition to his vegetable diet. On the other hand, he refuses to eat
meat, drink beer or smoke, all of which suggest certain unconscious inhibitions in this
area. In addition, he has a pathological fear of poisoning by mouth, and has shown an
obsessional preoccupation at times with mouth washing. These suggest a reaction formation
or defense against an unacceptable tendency to take something into his mouth or get
something out which from one point of view appears to be disgusting. In this
connection we must not forget his resolve to starve himself to death after the failure of
the Beer Hall Putsch, his hysterical mutism at the end of the last war, and his love of
speaking. The significance of these we shall consider later on.
Disturbance of love relations.
The second effect of his mother's pregnancy was his estrangement from her. The direct
result of this was, on the one hand, an idealization of love but without a sexual
component and, on the other hand, the setting up of a barrier against intimate
relationships with other people, particularly women. Having been hurt once, he
unconsciously guards himself against a similar hurt in the future. In his relationship to
his niece, Geli, he tried to overcome this barrier but he was again disappointed and since
then has not exposed himself to a really intimate relationship either with man or woman.
He has cut himself off from the world in which love plays any part for fear of being hurt
and what love he can experience is fixated on the abstract entity - Germany, which, as we
have seen, is a symbol of his ideal mother. This is a love relationship in which sex plays
no direct part.
Origin of his perversion.
The third outcome of his mother's pregnancy was to arouse an excessive curiosity. The
great mystery to children of this age, who find themselves in this situation, is how the
unborn child got into the mother's stomach and how it is going to get out. Even in cases
where the children have witnessed parental intercourse, this event is rarely linked with
the ensuing pregnancy. Since, in their limited experience, everything that gets into their
stomach enters by way of the mouth and everything that comes out usually does so by way of
the rectum, they are prone to believe that conception somehow takes place through the
mouth and that the child will be born via the anus. Hitler, as a child, undoubtedly
adhered to this belief but this did not satisfy his curiosity. He evidently wanted to see
for himself how it came out and exactly what happened.
This curiosity laid the foundation for his strange perversion which brought all three
of his sexualized zones into play. In her description of sexual experiences with Hitler,
Geli stressed the fact that it was of the utmost importance to him that she squat over him
in such a way that he could see everything. It is interesting, that Roehm, in an entirely
different connection, once said:
"He (Hitler) is thinking about the peasant girls. When they stand in the fields
and bend down at their work so that you can see their behinds, that's what he likes,
especially when they've got big round ones. That's Hitler's sex life. What a man."
Hitler, who was present, did not stir a muscle but only stared at Roehm with compressed
lips.
Psychological Analysis Part III
Table of Contents Page
|