Back MAZAL LIBRARY


.. I DID NOT KILL GOD
 .  
.   A Holocaust Poem
 .  
 .  By Berthold Goldman
©1994
.



1 9 5 0

So many voices competing
Since the beginning of time,
God is his alone, each one insists,
And only he owns truth.
Apparently truth is sold in the market place
To the one who pays,
Screams, hates and lies the most.
All others are wrong, they slander and cheat,
And face eternal damnation
If they do not believe.
Leaders throughout time claim to be more,
Know more then God,
Damn, often kill,
All that dare differ in their ways,
And preach hate, inequality, injustice and death
In His name.
I wish religions and governments understand:
BEFORE GOD AND PEOPLE -
ALL PEOPLE ARE EQUAL.

It's easy to speak with authority,
Controlled by ignorance and hate,
About creation, humanity,
Things and thoughts unknown.
It's easy to speak with certainty, arrogance,
And verbal violence
About the Creator of the universe.
The crimes against my people,
Committed time and again
For two thousand years,
I now understand.
Religious and political leaders,
In the name of God,
Made us symbols of hate to kill
And serve the state.
The Vatican never understood us in the past,
Nor do they understand us today.
THIS CENTURY ALONE THEY SACRIFICED
SIX TO SEVEN MILLION OF MY PEOPLE
ON THE ALTAR OF HATE.

They have no right to deny me even the thought,
That God may also be mine.
Their glorious ceremonies, chants, incense,
Rituals and costumes are the best of all
And mine are less than dirt, they say.
NOT GOD — THEY —
DENY ME THE RIGHT TO PRAY!
After all, the Vatican claims without proof,
With hate,
I KILLED GOD!

Justice, why do you hide
Your battered face in shame,
When I have been bloodied,
Accused, condemned
And cursed in mock trials,
Based on religious writings,
And truth twisted beyond recognition
For one execution on the cross by the Romans
In Jerusalem about 1900 years ago?
Only the Vatican knows the truth, they insist.
I know their truth is a myth.

The Vatican, Rome, taught the world
A tradition of hate,
Separation, injustice and inequality
For 1700 years,
Ever since in God's name instigated
Wars, misery and death,
Not to only against us, but against
All Christians who differ in their ways.
The Vatican insists no one else has the right
To speak to and for God.
The responsibility for the Holocaust
Belongs to the Vatican alone.
For revenge they spread hate, lied and killed
For 1700 years and declared ever
Since with great fanfare:
I KILLED GOD!

God and truth cleared my ancestors of a crime
We did not commit.
THEY DID NOT, NOR DID I KILL GOD!
I do not understand, it makes no sense,
Why must I be beaten and suffer
For a crime I did not commit,
Because 1900 years ago I did not live?

One evening during Atonement Services
In my synagogue,
I closed my eyes and asked:
"Lord above, please hear me,
If You care to hear me,
I speak with tears in my heart
And fire in my soul,
So much death, so much hate,
Tell me please, do YOU really need
Ceremonies, chants, prayers, incense,
To honor YOU on YOUR throne?
WHAT OF THE PRAYERS
OF THE POPE AND THE NAZIS,
WHO THINK IT WAS, STILL IS,
THEIR RIGHT TO INCITE AND KILL
IN YOUR NAME
SO MANY MILLIONS OF MY PEOPLE
OVER THOUSANDS OF YEARS OF PAIN!"

The answer disturbed me then as it does now.
A voice came into my mind and said:
"I DO NOT, BUT YOU DO!"

He spoke to me, I think He did, I know not why.
I should have asked Him then:
"Why do some of Your believers
Need human sacrifice?
To bribe You on Your throne?
To bestow on them all the riches of the world
And on us, to this day, early, painful deaths?"

THE VATICAN'S MERCILESS SILENCE,
NO, REFUSAL TO SPEAK
AND THEIR PRAYERS FOR VICTORY
FOR THE NAZI KILLING MACHINE
DURING THE BRUTAL EXTERMINATION
OF MY PEOPLE
IS A COMPLETE, CALLOUS DISREGARD,
DISRESPECT FOR GOD
AND THE HOLINESS OF LIFE
ON OUR PLANET.
DON' T YOU UNDERSTAND:
BEFORE GOD ALL PEOPLE ARE EQUAL.

Incredible, unbelievable,
The anti-Jewish Pope
In the Vatican,
During the Nazi killing years,
For approving murder
With chilling silence,
Prayers for victory for depraved killers
And no pity, no feeling whatsoever
For millions of innocent victims,
Not only of my people,
But of all races and religions,
And helping Nazis escape justice
After they lost the war,
Will soon be rewarded and proclaimed
A holy man, a saint.
The Vatican does not have the courage
To face its own guilt.
The Pope and the Vatican,
With their murderous Teaching of Hate,
Are as responsible for the Holocaust
As much as the Nazis were.
THE VATICAN'S HANDS
ARE AS BLOODY AS THEIRS.

One of your ancient prophesies stated:
If only all Jews were converted,
the Second Coming will be hastened.
THEY COULD NOT,
WILL NEVER CONVERT US!
Conversion obviously was not the solution.
To kill all of us all over the world,
With Nazi collusion,
Was, to them, the "logical" conclusion,
THE FINAL SOLUTION.

The Vatican and the Nazis prayed to YOU
To approve their killing deeds.
To kill and torture for revenge,
To please and honor YOU on YOUR throne.

As GOD'S only self-appointed,
Prejudiced voice,
Justice forgotten,
They forgave the Nazis and themselves,
In GOD'S name of course,
For all the crimes they committed.
Not guilty they said,
After all corpses and ashes
Are not acceptable witnesses!
Justice, where do you hide in shame?
Even this day, right after the Holocaust,
They insist I killed the Lord!

I know not why, in my sleep,
Words from Beyond flowed into my soul.
I think, to ease my pain,
He spoke to me:
"I abhor human sacrifice with passion,
The crime they committed,
Spilling innocent blood,
Any blood, is the most depraved of sins!
Answer for it in time they will.
All people before Me are equal,
Regardless of religion or color of skin.
I gave you free will, use it well, learn,
For your sake, THINK!"
"Forgive me for questioning, Lord,
Of doubt and justice I speak,
I do not understand, if the Vatican and the Nazis
Are not willing to listen and THINK,
What good will come from "Answer in Time"?

Can "Answer in Time" return life
To millions of my people,
Tortured to death and buried in slime?"
Perhaps if the world's religions can be convinced
ALL PEOPLE ARE EQUAL,
If we eliminate organized people extermination
For whatever religious and political reason,
Some good can come out of this crime.

1 9 9 9

MY ANCESTORS DID NOT KILL GOD!
They have no right even this day,
To deny me the thought
That God may also be mine.
God does not listen to prayers of Jews,
A different Christian denomination proclaims,
Based on the Vatican's traditional,
Deadly teaching of hate,
Despite an ignored statement
Some years ago by a Pope,
Absolving us of "collective guilt"?
For a crime we did not commit.

The Teaching of Hate continues
As if nothing happened,
Despite the Vatican's
Recent declarations of regret
For far too many millions dead.

I never was religious in any sense.
Why should I believe in GOD?
Where was HE
When too many millions of my people,
With gloating and indifference
From the Vatican,
Were tortured, gassed and burned to death
And their bones and ashes
Barely covered with dirt?

They should have tried to save Jewish lives.
To honor GOD, for the sake of humanity,
Any true religion
Has the sacred obligation to intervene, to help,
Regardless of consequences
And other convictions,
After all, so they preach,
We are our brothers' keepers.

The Vatican is first and foremost, political,
And does not necessarily represent
The Catholic Church,
The Holy Spirit of its people.

Your preaching killed
Too many millions of my people
Over thousands of years because you hate.
Despite recent declarations of remorse,
To this day the Vatican
Does not have the courage
To eliminate hate and lies,
Inserted into the New Testament
Long before my time,
For political reasons and power,
To appease a pagan emperor of Rome,
Help him control his citizens
And make Christianity
The only religion of state.
At times I do believe in GOD.

When I look into babies' sparkling eyes
And see love.
To my regret, when I wake up
And look at reality, I do not.
I find it hard, very hard, to believe.
I want to learn. I would like to believe.
Why? How?
This I know from bitter experience,
Ignorance, hate, arrogance, segregation
And sick imagination
Are parts of a dangerous, deadly farce.

Fanatical hate from the Vatican
Almost killed my mother and later me
When I was very young.
Why must I be punished for a crime
I did not commit?
MY ANCESTORS DID NOT KILL GOD!

I DARE SPEAK FOR GOD,
THE FINAL JUDGE,
WHO LOOKS ON US FROM ABOVE.
THE POISON SEEDS
THE VATICAN PLANTED
IN PEOPLE'S MINDS SO LONG AGO,
THIS DAY LIVES AND GROWS.
I HOPE IT NEVER AGAIN
VOMITS OUT ITS DEADLY HATE.

AS LONG AS WORDS OF HATE
REMAIN IN THE NEW TESTAMENT
AND IN YOUR HEART,
ALL DECLARATIONS OF REMORSE
MEAN NOTHING,
AND THE VATICAN CONTINUES
TO BETRAY GOD'S TEACHING,
HIS TRUST, JUSTICE, US,
IT'S OWN FAITHFUL BELIEVERS
AND ALL OTHERS
WHO SEARCH FOR LOVE.

WHERE IS THE LOVE YOU PREACH?
WHY DO YOU HATE?
WE WILL REMEMBER FOREVER,
BUT WE DO NOT HATE!
WE DID NOT KILL GOD!

2000

For my people the tragedies and lessons
Of the 20th century were deadly indeed.
Unending religious intolerance, arrogance,
Blind nationalistic and ethnic hate,
Too many millions killed before their time,
I wish, I wish, I wish, oh how I wish
For the right in peace to live!
I wonder, what was, still is, my crime?
This late I know my wish is but a dream,
A shimmering cloud I can not touch,
Floating aimlessly around the moon
In the darkness of the night,
An illusion, with no substance,
Disintegrating into nothing
In the sun's morning light.

Nothing changed,
Despite the deadly lessons
Of history and misery of the past,
Which disturb us now and forever will.
The forces of evil, all from the same origin,
Stirred by fanatics of many different religions
And lead by political criminals,
Both working hand in hand,
Are as deadly now as ever before.

Where is GOD'S place
In this equation of lies and slander,
This millennium old legacy
Of hate, pain and death,
All proclaimed in HIS name?

It is so much easier to hate!
Was GOD ever, face to face, asked
By those who claim to speak for Him:
"Is hate and killing to honor YOU just?"

Remarks of regret from the Vatican
For six to seven million dead are but a sham,
An attempted cover up, to deny in time,
That the Holocaust ever happened.

We, the victims, are and will be blamed
For the killing fields and smoking chimneys
Of the Holocaust crime,
To forget the collective guilt
Of the Vatican and the Nazis in time.

Only they are holy, they claim.
The world will believe.
After all, so they say, they do not lie.
To them we are but slime.

It's so easy, terribly easy, to hate.
It takes effort, openness and heart, to love.
WE DID NOT KILL GOD!

I want this clearly understood,
The Vatican, political,
Not the Catholic Church, religious,
Denies Israel and all Jews,
Even to this day, the right to exist.

They still, this late, hate.
WE DID NOT KILL GOD!

The lives of six to seven million Jews
Were offered as a burnt sacrifice
On the altar of hate — to honor GOD?

How dare the Vatican,
After all that has happened,
Continue to hate
In HIS name to avenge a myth?

GOD CAN NOT BE KILLED!
GOD IS ALIVE. HE NEVER DIED!



* . {short description of image}