| |
such an application only if unusual
circumstances make it necessary to have a judge conduct such
preexamination."¹ |
| An illuminating comment on the law is made by
a German text writer. |
| |
"A criminal case on which verdict
has been passed must not again become the subject of another criminal
proceeding. This exclusive effect pertains to the subject of the case both as
regards the crime and the criminal. * * According to the findings of the German
supreme court and to the prevailing theory in accord with these findings, the
effect of ne bis in idem includes the history of the case submitted to
the court for verdict. * * * This theory, however, leads to unbearable
consequences. In order to avoid these unbearable consequences some courts,
recently, have permitted the breach of the principle against double jeopardy in
exceptional cases where jeopardy of a second trial is necessitated by the sound
sense of justice. * * * " ² |
| On 21 March 1942 Adolf Hitler promulgated a
decree regarding the simplification of the administration of justice. We quote
the following excerpts: |
| |
"In penal cases, * * * the formal
opening of the main proceeding must be eliminated. * * * (Sec. I.)
"Indictments and judicial decisions must be more tersely written by
restricting them to the absolutely necessary. (Sec. II.)
"The
cooperation of professional associate judges in judicial decisions must be
restricted. (Sec. III.)
"I commission the Reich Minister of Justice, in
agreement with the Reich Minister and Chief of the Reich Chancellery and with
the Chief of the Party Chancellery, to issue the legal provisions necessary for
the execution of this decree. I empower the Reich Minister of Justice to make
the necessary administrative provisions and to decide any doubtful questions by
administrative means. (Sec. VI.)" |
On 13 August 1942 a decree was issued by the
defendant Schlegelberger as Reich Minister of Justice in charge of the
Ministry |
| |
"Article 4. * * * Decisions by the
criminal court, the Special Court, and the criminal senate of the circuit
courts of appeal may be made solely by the president or his regular deputy, if
he considers the cooperation of his associates dispensable in view of the
simplicity of the nature and the legal status of the case, and if the public
prosecutor agrees. |
__________ ¹ Ibid., article 4, 1,
a. ² "German Criminal Procedure," by Heinrich Henkel, (Hamburg 1943)
pages 440-442.
1008 |