| |
Reich Physicians' Leader; he will, therefore, to a certain
degree, easily be regarded as the representative of the German medical
profession during the Hitler regime. Now, there is great danger that the entire
German medical profession will be identified with its former leader, Dr. Conti,
and with the crimes he was charged with during this trial; the German medical
profession fears that those crimes which, in fact, were committed by
individual doctors, who may have been rightly charged, are to be taken
as typical of the entire medical profession. Indeed, during the last months we
could hear in the press and on the radio that the entire medial profession was
here in the prisoners' dock; unfortunately, by thus generalizing, the matter
was presented as though the entire medical profession was corrupt and that the
majority of German physicians had committed such crimes or at least approved
them, as stated here in the indictment at the trial. This conception is wrong
and unjust. The German medical profession numbered about 80,000 members and if
we add the Wehrmacht physicians and the official physicians, one arrives at
about 100.000 physicians. Now let us compare with this total number the small
number of physicians and researchers here in the dock. There are altogether 20
men. Of what importance is such an insignificant number for the judging of the
entire profession? If out of 5,000 German physicians one single person
committed a crime, it is impossible to draw a conclusion from these few
exceptions regarding the behavior and morals of the whole class. And even if we
suppose that perhaps another few hundred physicians and researchers not here in
the dock had taken part in the "experiments on human beings" and in
the "euthanasia action", the number of guilty persons in comparison
with the total number of the entire profession is still too small to entitle
one to consider the entire profession as criminal, and morally inferior because
some individuals committed a wrong.
There is yet another point of view. It stands to reason that not all
experiments on human beings can be excused and justified, not even during a
time of total warfare and under a dictatorship, and no decent person would ever
think of excusing the way and manner in which the Hitler State carried out the
"Euthanasia Program." However, it is an incontestable fact that
large-scale experiments on human beings cannot altogether be avoided and are,
in fact, carried out throughout the whole world, and that there are different
viewpoints concerning the problem of euthanasia, even to a limited extent in
the circles of conscientious physicians when this is carried out on a proper
legal basis, and when, in addition, full precautions are taken to prevent
abuses. It must not be overlooked that the deterioration of the medical
87
|